Sybil Niden Goldrich
Ernest Hornsby, Esq.
Dianna Pendleton-Dominguez, Esq.
CLAIMANTS' ADVISORY COMMITTEE E-NEWSLETTER
Volume 4, No. 7, October 1, 2007
This is the 37th e-newsletter (Vol. 4, No. 7) from the Claimants' Advisory Committee (CAC) in the Dow Corning bankruptcy Settlement Plan. You were sent a copy of the newsletter because our records show that you requested to be on the mailing list. If you wish to unsubscribe or to reply to this newsletter, send an email to: info@tortcomm.org. Please do not hit "Reply" to this email address. Please use the email address: info@tortcomm.org.
Requests for copies of claim forms or inquiries about the status of a claim should be directed to the Settlement Facility at info@sfdct.com or 866-874-6099. The Claimants’ Advisory Committee does not have access to individual claimant files to answer these kinds of questions.
1. SF-DCT RELEASES CLAIMS CRITERIA INFORMATION FOR POLYMYOSITIS AND DERMATOMYOSITIS CLAIMS
Pursuant to an Agreed Order Resetting Final Disease Cure Deadlines entered by the Court on June 15, 2007, the SF-DCT is releasing claims criteria information for two eligible diseases in the Plan: Polymyositis and Dermatomyositis. A copy of the document is available on the CAC website (www.tortcomm.org) under the heading “Disease Claims” or on the SF-DCT website (www.sfdct.com). Claimants and attorneys affected by the cure deadline extension for Polymyositis or Dermatomyositis will be sent a new Notification of Status letter from the SF-DCT with a final cure deadline for these claims.
The CAC is continuing to work with the SF-DCT about release of additional disease and disability criteria. The Agreed Order provides that the SF-DCT will release claims criteria information on Primary Sjogren’s Syndrome (PSS), Mixed Connective Tissue Disease (MCTD) and Overlap Syndrome (OS) on or by November 1, 2007.
2. CLAIMS PAYMENT AND PROCESSING REPORT
The Settlement Facility has released information about the status of claims processing and payment through AUGUST 31, 2007. The information is summarized below.
Through AUGUST 31, 2007, the Settlement Facility has received 75,021 Proof of Manufacturer claim forms in Classes 5, 6.1 and 6.2. Of the 75,021 claims, 60,752 or 81% have acceptable proof of a Dow Corning breast implant.
Through August 31, 2007, the SF-DCT has issued payment to claimants in Classes 5 and 6 (Dow Corning breast implant claimants) totaling approximately $889 million, including almost $400 million in approved rupture payments.
Claim Category
|
Number of Claims Paid through August 31, 2007
|
Percentage of Claims Approved Class 5 | Class 6
|
Total $$ Paid in category through August 31, 2007
|
RUPTURE
|
20,321
|
70% | 44%
|
$396,683,865.97
|
EXPLANT
|
26,735
|
99% | 95%
|
$129,921,299.08
|
EXPLANT ASSISTANCE
|
502
|
89% | 50%
|
$2,490,141.10
|
INCREASE EXPLANT (6.2 ONLY)
|
35
|
N/A | 89%
|
$105,000.00
|
EXPEDITED RELEASE
|
15,500
|
90% | 71%
|
$29,200,855.86
|
DISEASE OPTION 1
|
17,990
|
79 % | 50%
|
$265,557,590.51
|
DISEASE OPTION 2
|
525
|
18% | 7%
|
$64,897,557.50
|
Total
|
81,608
|
N/A
|
$888,856,310.02
|
Note: The approval percentages for Disease Options 1 and 2 include those claims that were previously approved by the MDL 926 Claims Office and are Opass through O in the Settlement Facility (i.e., the claimant had an implant from Bristol, Baxter or 3M and a breast implant from Dow Corning and has applied to receive 50% of her disease award in the Dow Corning case). As a result, the percentage of approved Disease claims processed by the Settlement Facility if actually lower.
CLASS 7 (SILICONE GEL MATERIAL CLAIMANTS)
Claim Category
|
Number of Forms Filed
|
Approved & Paid - Foreign Gel
|
Approved & Paid Expedited
|
Approved Offers
|
Total Approved
|
Total Ineligible
|
Pending Pom 1st Review
|
Proof of Manufacturer
|
54531
|
586
|
4802
|
5117
|
10505
|
29164
|
14011
|
CLASS 9, 10.1 and 10.2 (DCC "COVERED" OTHER PRODUCTS)
Claim Category
|
Number of Forms Filed
|
Number of Claims Reviewed
|
Number of Claims Approved
|
Number of Claims for Benefits Reviewed
|
Number of Claims for Benefits Approved
|
Percentage of Claims Approved
|
PROOF OF MANUFACTURER
|
7258
|
7203
|
2477
|
7203
|
2477
|
34%
|
EXPEDITED RELEASE
|
3946
|
1498
|
1515
|
1498
|
1515
|
100%
|
RUPTURE (Chin and Testicular)
|
564
|
115
|
23
|
115
|
23
|
20%
|
INFLAMMATORY FOREIGN BODY RESP. (TMJ, finger, wrist, toe, knee & hip)
|
1722
|
647
|
350
|
647
|
350
|
54%
|
IMPLANT FAILURE (TMJ, finger wrist, toe knee, hip & testicular)
|
2323
|
786
|
99
|
786
|
99
|
13%
|
TMJ ENHANCED
|
1273
|
345
|
29
|
345
|
29
|
8%
|
3.UPDATE ON NOI CLAIMS SETTLEMENT STATUS
As noted in prior CAC e-newsletters, there has been a settlement that now allows timely NOI claimants to apply for and, if eligible, receive benefits for Explant and Rupture. The SF-DCT is preparing to mail information about this settlement to timely NOI or Conditional claimants in the next few weeks.
The deadline for timely NOI claimants covered by the settlement to apply for Explant and Rupture benefits is October 20, 2008. This means that timely NOI claimants who want to recover for Explant ($5,000 U.S.) and/or Rupture ($20,000 U.S. Base Payment) must have their Dow Corning breast implants removed and their claim forms submitted to the SF-DCT by October 20, 2008. Please note that this deadline applies ONLY to NOI claimants. It does not apply to timely filed claimants.
NOI Claimants who are eligible and who want to accept the settlement now can sign and submit an “NOI Acceptance Form.” A copy of this form will be on the CAC website’s Home Page and also under the heading of “Rule 3005/Notice of Intent Issues.”
4.NEW LIST OF ACCEPTABLE AFFIRMATIVE STATEMENTS FOR DOW CORNING PROOF OF MANUFACTURER
On August 17, 2007, the SF-DCT made the following list of doctors available who have submitted an affirmative statement about their exclusive use of Dow Corning breast implants during the specific time frames listed.
SURGEON / PHYSICIAN NAME
|
LOCATION
|
TIME FRAME
|
Adrichem, Dr. LNA Van
|
The Netherlands
|
1965 - 1991
|
Agris, Dr. Joseph
|
Houston, TX
|
1982
|
Allen, Dr. John
|
Little Rock, AR
|
1974 - 1978
|
Allen, Dr. Thomas
|
Little Rock, AR
|
1970 - 1979
|
Altaney, Dr. Franklin
|
Charlotte, NC
|
1972
|
Anders, Dr. Christopher
|
Woking, Surrey
United Kingdom
|
1977
|
Apostolis, Dr. Charles G.
|
Port Elizabeth
South Africa
|
all years
|
Arends, Dr. Norman J.
|
Eastpointe, MI
|
1966- 1976
|
Arnold, Dr. J. Harold
|
Greenville, SC
|
1979
|
Au, Dr. Victor K.
|
Burlington, NC
|
All years
|
AZVU Facility
|
Amsterdam
Netherlands
|
1978
|
Bailey, Dr. Bruce
|
Aylesbury, Bucks
United Kingdom
|
all years
|
Banfield, Dr. Ernest
|
Tacoma, WA
|
1977
|
Bartlett, Dr. Sylvan
|
Odessa, TX
|
1981, 1983
|
Barton, Dr. Morris
|
Phoenix, AZ
|
1967- 1975
|
Beasley Jr, Dr. Gerald L.
|
Duncan, OK
|
All years
|
Beehan, Dr. Patrick
|
Hamilton
New Zealand
|
1985 - 1986
|
Beg, Dr. Saeed
|
Irving, TX
|
1981, 1983, 1986
|
Bell, Dr. Gordon
|
Washington, D.C.
|
1971
|
Berg, Dr. Elliot M.
|
Baltimore, MD
|
1964 - 1973
|
Biggs, Dr. Thomas
|
Houston, TX
|
1973, 1978, 1980- 1983
|
Blake, Dr. Graeme
|
Merivale, Christchurch
New Zealand
|
1979 - 1980, 1983 - 1984, 1990
|
Bloomenstein, Dr. Richard
|
Englewood, NJ
|
1969, 1972
|
Bowen, Dr. John
|
London
United Kingdom
|
1974-1979
|
1982-1988
Broomhead, Dr. I. W.
|
United Kingdom
|
1977
|
Brown, Dr. Earl
|
New Zealand
|
1980
|
Brucker, Dr. Perry
|
Fort Wayne, IN
|
1968
|
Buffington, Dr. F.C.
|
Norman, OK
|
All years
|
Bumagin, Dr. Michael S.
|
Fort Worth, TX
|
All years
|
Bussey, Dr. Joseph G.
|
Austell, GA
|
1970 - 1982
|
Calcinai, Dr. Colin
|
Wellington, New Zealand
|
1976, 1981
|
Caplitz, Dr. I.W.
|
Mukegon County, MI
|
1968
|
Carrell, Dr. Jeffrey M.
|
Buffalo, NY
|
1970's & 1980's
|
Ceber, Dr. Simon
|
Kew, Victoria Australia
|
1976
|
Church, Dr. James Escott
|
New Zealand
|
All Years
|
Cipcic, Dr. J.A.
|
Steubenville, OH
|
All years
|
Clarendon, Dr. Colin C.D.
|
Memphis, TN
|
1972 - 1976
|
Clayton, Dr. James M.
|
Provo, Utah
|
1981-1990
|
Cochran, Dr. Thomas C.
|
Boston, MA
|
1972, 1978
|
Comess, Dr. Morton
|
Phoenix, AZ
|
All years
|
Constanza, Dr. Landelino
|
Guatemala
|
1977
|
Corbin, Dr. Frederic H.
|
Brea, CA
|
1984-1990
|
Craft, Dr. Jerome/Craft Surgical Center
|
West Palm Beach, FL
|
1972-1990
|
DeProphetis, Dr. Nino
|
Wallingford, PA
|
All years
|
Dibble, Dr. Wayne R.
|
Haverhill, MA
|
1980 - 1982
|
Dotson, Dr. Daniel A.
|
Graham, TX
|
All years
|
Dubin, Dr. Bruce
|
Newport Beach, CA
|
1986 - 1989
|
Duckett, Dr. James
|
Oklahoma City, OK
|
1966-1971
|
Duffy, Dr. Michael M.
|
San Antonio, TX
|
All years
|
Dyer, Dr. Peggy
|
Baton Rouge, LA
|
1975-1980
|
Easterly, James
|
Winter Park, FL
|
All Years
|
El Sigai, Dr. Ahmed
|
Germany
|
1988
|
Elam, Dr. Michael
|
Newport Beach, CA
|
1978, 1982-1986
|
Estima, Dr. Antonio Costa
|
Brazil
|
1976
|
Ewalt, Dr. Donald H.
|
El Paso, TX
|
1967 - 1974
|
Finger, Dr. E. Ronald
|
Savannah, GA
|
1975
|
Florman, Dr. Larry D.
|
Louisville, KY
|
1974 - 1984
|
Foster, Dr. Lawrence
|
South Lake Tahoe, CA
|
1970-1974
|
Fowlow, Dr. W.A.
|
Calgary, Alberta CANADA
|
1972-1977, 1981
|
Frederickson, Dr. Eric Allan
|
Hingham, MA
|
1970 - 1985
|
Fromm, Dr. Harold E.
|
Rapid City, SD
|
All years
|
Gallagher, Dr. Pamela M.
|
Mineola, NY
|
1980, 1984, 1985
|
Garcia, Dr. F.A.
|
Denver, CO
|
All years
|
Garre, Dr. William C.
|
Dallas, TX
|
1972
|
Gaska, Dr. Walter
|
Springfield, MO
|
All years
|
Gaston, Dr. Erskin A.
|
Dallas, TX
|
1970 - 1979
|
Gilbert, Dr. Stephen
|
New Zealand
|
1983 - 1986
|
Gilman Hospital
|
St. Mary's, GA
|
All years
|
Given, Dr. Kenna
|
Augusta, GA
|
1978
|
Gorman, Dr. John B.
|
Oxnard, CA
|
1986-1987
|
Goulian, Dr. Dicran
|
New York, NY
|
1971 - 1975
|
Griffiths, Dr. Cadvan O.
|
Los Angeles, CA
|
All years
|
Gsell, Dr. F.
|
Germany
|
1970 - 1979
|
Guerra, Dr. Cesar H.
|
Amarillo, TX
|
1974-1979
|
Habal, Dr. Mutaz
|
Tampa, FL
|
1983 - 1985
|
Hackett, Dr. M.E.J.
|
Essex
United Kingdom
|
1983-1988
|
Halbert, Dr. David S.
|
Abilene, TX
|
1975 - 1976
|
Harris, David L.
|
United Kingdom
|
1987
|
Hause, Dr. Dwight
|
Corpus Christi, TX
|
All years
|
Herman, Dr. Steven
|
New York, NY
|
Prior to 1981
|
Heycock, Dr. M.H.
|
United Kingdom
|
1974-1979
|
Hilbun, Dr. Glyn R.
|
Pascagoula, MS
|
All years
|
Hirsche, Dr. Blayne L.
|
Provo, Utah
|
1982-1990
|
Hirshowitz, Dr. Bernard
|
Israel
|
1971 and 1984
|
Hobby, Dr. J. A. E.
|
Salsibury, United Kingdom
|
1977, 1988
|
Howe, Dr. Robert E.
|
Birmingham, AL
|
1972 -1978
|
Huttner, Dr. Donald
|
Westminister, CO
|
1976, 1980, 1981, 1982, 1985
|
Ibrahim, Dr. Kaissar S.
|
Raleigh, NC
|
All years
|
Illiescu, Dr. John
|
Reno, Nevda
|
1974 - 1979
|
Jackson, Dr. Ian T.
|
United Kingdom
|
1972-1979
|
Jatoi, Dr. Alimadad
|
Bedford, TX
|
All years
|
Kauffmann, Dr. Adolph F.
|
Fort Worth, Texas
|
1970 - 1974
|
Klein, Dr. Daniel
|
Brooklyn, NY
|
All years
|
Koire, Dr. Bernard
|
Los Angeles, CA
|
1968-1969
|
Kruggel, Dr. John
|
San Diego, CA
|
1968-1974
|
Kunze, Dr. Hans-Henning
|
Germany
|
1970 - 1979
|
Lamaker, Dr. J.H.
|
Netherlands
|
1970-1979
|
Liechavicius, Dr. Nelson
|
Brazil
|
1978
|
Lindsay, Dr. John
|
Fort Worth, TX
|
1978-1984
|
Lovie, Dr. Maxwell J.
|
New Zealand
|
1968-1973
|
Lu, Dr. Milton M.
|
Lancaster, PA
|
1971 - 1974
|
Manchester, Dr. William M.
|
New Zealand
|
All Years
|
Mansel, Dr. R.E.
|
Wales, United Kingdom
|
1980-1986, 1990
|
Maraist, Dr. Donald J.
|
Jefferson County, TX
|
All years
|
Martin, Dr. Fred R.
|
Tulsa, OK
|
1979 - 1983
|
Martin, Dr. Mary M.
|
Cincinnati, OH
|
all years
|
Mauldin, Dr. Howard P.
|
Oklahoma City, OK
|
1977
|
McCarty, Dr. Gordon E.
|
Phillips County, AR
|
All years
|
McCurdy, Dr. William C.
|
Norman, OK
|
1982 - 1984
|
McCurdy, Dr. John A.
|
Wailuku, Honolulu, Hi
|
1983-1986
|
McDougall, Dr. Ian A.
|
Australia
|
1979, 1990
|
McKeon, Dr. James
|
New Orleans, LA
|
1973
|
Mehrotra, Dr. Onka
|
New Zealand
|
all
|
Miliken, Dr. Thomas
|
New Zealand
|
All years
|
Millard-Henry Clinic
|
Russellville, AR
|
1977 - 1980
|
Mitts, Dr.Thomas F.
|
Fresno, CA
|
1988-1991
|
Montgomery, Dr. Wally
|
Paducah, KY
|
All years
|
Mountfort, Dr. Paul
|
New Zealand
|
1968-1985
|
Moyd, Dr. Pickens
|
Hartsville, SC
|
1975 - 1976
|
Nichol, Dr. Tom D.
|
Louisville, KY
|
1974 - 1981
|
Olivari, Dr. Neven
|
Germany
|
all years
|
Ozment, Dr. Kerry
|
Little Rock, AR
|
1970-1975
|
Pastseavouras, Dr. Louie
|
Gtreensboro, NC
|
1974-1979
|
Peddy, Dr. Robert B.
|
Lakeland, FL
|
All years
|
Pflugbeil, Dr. Ernst
|
Germany
|
1970-1975
|
Phillips, Dr. Curtis
|
Jacksonville, FL
|
1973 - 1980
|
Pilnet, Dr. Frank
|
St. Paul, MN
|
1973-1975
|
Pinkner, Dr. Lawrence D.
|
Owings Mills and Westminster, MD
|
All years
|
Pullman, Dr. Norman K.
|
Wichita, KS
|
All years
|
Quiroz, Dr. Alejandro
|
San Deigo, CA
|
1991
|
Ramselaar, Dr. J.M.
|
The Netherlands
|
1976 - 1991
|
Rappaport, Dr. Irving
|
Tustin, CA
|
1970, 1978
|
Reid, Dr. William Henry
|
Glascow, United Kingdom
|
November 1975 - 1984
|
Robbins, Dr. Lawrence B.
|
Miami, FL
|
All years
|
Robertson, Dr. James G.
|
Miami, FL
|
1967 and 1974 - 1978
|
Robinson, Dr. O. Gordon
|
Birmingham, Alabama
|
to 12/31/1973
|
Rogers, Dr. Charles S.
|
Bay City, MI
|
All years
|
Rossell, Dr. Enrique
|
Guatemala
|
1975-1978
|
Rygiel, Dr. Witold
|
Lake Havasu City, AZ
|
1974- 1985
|
Schultz, Dr. K.D.
|
Germany
|
1976, 1979
|
Schwartz, Dr. Ralph
|
Livonia, MI
|
1974
|
Shaheen, Dr. Albert H.
|
Utica, NY
|
All years
|
Shepard, Dr. Glen
|
Newport News, VA
|
1973-1974
|
1976-1978
Sherman, Dr. Stanley
|
Aventura, FL
|
1975, 1985-1986
|
Simon, Dr. Duncan
|
New Zealand
|
1972-1987
|
Simpson, Dr. John
|
Wellington, New Zealand
|
1989-1991
|
Sint Franciscus Gasthuis (facility)
|
The Netherlands
|
1965 - 1991
|
Slater, Dr. Paul
|
Cheyenne, WY
|
1979
|
Smith, Dr. Burwell R.
|
Charleston, SC
|
1977 - 1980
|
Sommerlad, Dr. Brian C.
|
Essex
England
|
1985
|
Spira, Dr. Melvin
|
Houston, TX
|
1972 , 1974-1982, 1987-1989
|
St. Antonius Hospital
|
Amsterdam, Netherlands
|
1976, 1979, 1980, 1983, 1984
|
Stark, Dr. Richard B.
|
New York, NY
|
All years
|
Steen, Dr. Alan
|
St. Helena, CA
|
1970-1974
|
Steen, Dr. Alan M.
|
St. Helena, California
|
1970-1974
|
Stillwell, Dr. James
|
Tacoma, WA
|
1977
|
Terino, Dr. Edward
|
Thosand Oaks, CA
|
1970
|
Thompson, Dr. R.V.S.
|
Cooma, Pambula, and Tura Beach,
NSW Austalia
|
All years
|
Tombini, Dr. Sergio
|
LaGuna Niguel, CA
|
1973
|
Trusler, Dr. H. Marshall
|
Carmel, IN
|
1975-1978
|
Uebel, Dr. Carlos
|
Porto Alegre
Brazil
|
1986-1989
|
University Of Texas Medical Branch at Galveston
|
Galveston, TX
|
1969 - 1975
|
Vincent, Dr. John Robert
|
Memphis, TN
|
1968 - 1974
|
Wagner, Dr. Kurt
|
Boca Raton, Florida
|
1966 - 1/1/1972
|
Walker, Dr. Peter
|
New Zealand
|
1985 - 1986
|
Wallace, Anthony F.
|
Essex
United Kingdom
|
all years
|
Ward, Dr. Christopher M.
|
London
United Kingdom
|
1979 - 1985
|
Weatherly, Dr. Weatherly-White
|
Denver, CO
|
1968-1975
|
Weiner, Daniel
|
New York, NY
|
1990 - 1/1/1992
|
Wilhelmsen, Dr. Hans
|
Baltimore, MD
|
1970 - 1972, 1974
|
Wilkinson, Dr. Tolbert S.
|
San Antonio, Texas
|
1972-1973
|
Williams, Dr. John
|
New Zealand
|
1972-1979 1990
|
Williams, Dr. John E.
|
Beverly Hills, CA
|
1965-1970
|
Wilson, Dr. H Keith Forbes
|
New Zealand
|
1972, 1980 - 1984
|
Wilson, Dr. John M.
|
Darlington, SC
|
All years
|
Wood, Dr. W. Graham
|
Clarksville, AR
|
1988
|
Wood, Dr. W. Graham
|
Newport Beach, CA
|
1991
|
Worthern, Dr. Eugene
|
Monroe, LA
|
1965-1980
|
Wynn-Williams, Dr. David
|
Nottingham
United Kingdom
|
1968, 1974, 1976
|
Yarn, Dr. Charles
|
Atlanta, GA
|
All years
|
Zahorsky, Dr. Carroll
|
Overland Park, KS
|
1971
|
Zeller, Dr. Frank
|
Winter Haven, FL
|
All years
|
Zielinski, Dr. Victor
|
Sydney
NSW Australia
|
All years
|
Zufi, Dr. David
|
Coral Gables, FL
|
1974-1975, 1983 |
5. DEADLINE REMINDERS!
Please mark your calendar with the claim submission deadlines. Please note that most of these deadlines mean that your claim forms and materials must be received by the SF-DCT by the posted deadline. Please mail all forms early enough so that they are received by the deadline listed below. If your claim form is not received by the deadline listed below, you will not be permitted to file a claim later.
Deadline Date | Type of Deadline |
October 20, 2008 | NOI CLAIMANTS’ Deadline to submit Explant and/or Rupture claims – Classes 5, 6.1 and 6.2 |
June 2, 2014 | Explant Claims submission deadline for Classes 5, 6.1 and 6.2 |
June 3, 2019 | Disease or Expedited Release Claim submission deadline for Classes 5, 6.1 and 6.2 |
If you would like to read prior CAC e-newsletters, they are available on the CAC website by clicking on "Electronic Newsletter." We urge you to visit the CAC website (www.tortcomm.org) on a regular basis to download or view relevant documents and read updates and new information. To contact the CAC, send an email to: info@tortcomm.org or send a letter to the Post Office Box address for the CAC at:
Claimants’ Advisory Committee
P.O. Box 665
St. Marys, Ohio 45885
NOTICE: This document is copyrighted. You are not authorized to post it on any website without express, prior written permission of the Claimants’ Advisory Committee.
|